Spendthrift Trust: Pros and Cons, Tax Benefits, and How They Work
As Featured on
Contents
- What Is a Spendthrift Trust?
- How Does a Spendthrift Trust Work?
- Who Needs a Spendthrift Trust?
- Pros and Cons of Spendthrift Trusts
- Advantages
- Disadvantages
- Setting Up a Spendthrift Trust
- Common Spendthrift Trust Examples
- Example 1: The Young Heir
- Example 2: The Financially Vulnerable Beneficiary
- Spendthrift Trusts vs. Other Options
- Tax Implications of Spendthrift Trusts
- State Laws and Spendthrift Trusts
- Common Questions About Spendthrift Trusts
- Is a Spendthrift Trust Right for You?
- Alternatives to Consider
- Ready to Protect Your Legacy?
Wealth protection isn’t just about building assets—it’s about making sure they last. And one of the most common concerns we hear from clients is: “What happens to my money after I’m gone?”
It’s a fair question. You’ve spent decades building wealth, making smart decisions, and planning carefully. Then the thought hits you: what if your beneficiaries don’t handle that money with the same care?
Maybe your son has a spending problem. Perhaps your daughter married someone you don’t quite trust. Or maybe your grandchild is just too young to handle a large sum all at once.
Enter the spendthrift trust—a powerful but often misunderstood estate planning tool that lets you provide for your loved ones while protecting your legacy from poor decisions, creditors, and outside influences.
In this guide, we’ll cut through the legal jargon and explain clearly how these trusts work, when they make sense, and how to set one up properly.
What Is a Spendthrift Trust?
A spendthrift trust is a special type of trust that limits a beneficiary’s access to the trust’s assets. Unlike a regular trust that might hand over assets all at once, a spendthrift trust doles out money gradually according to the terms you set up.
The key feature is the “spendthrift clause” or “spendthrift provision.”
This language allows the trustee to limit or withhold distributions from the trust in specific situations—like if a beneficiary is being sued or owes a judgment. It can also let the trustee use trust funds to cover certain beneficiary expenses.
A spendthrift clause usually includes wording that gives the trustee the power to decide how to apply it, making it a “spendthrift discretionary trust.”
Think of it like this: Instead of giving someone a full tank of gas, you’re setting up a system that provides enough fuel for each leg of their journey.
What makes this different from simply telling a normal trustee to be careful with distributions? The legal power of the spendthrift provision. With this clause in place, your beneficiary legally cannot sell their interest in the trust, pledge it as collateral, or transfer it to others.
Even if they wanted to cash out their entire inheritance at once, they couldn’t. And when creditors come knocking, the trustee can essentially say: “Sorry, these assets don’t belong to the beneficiary—they belong to the trust.”
The beauty of this arrangement is that it can protect your heirs not just from outside threats, but sometimes from themselves. We’ve seen these trusts make the difference between an inheritance that’s gone in a year and one that supports a family for generations.
How Does a Spendthrift Trust Work?
A spendthrift trust has the same basic components as other trusts:
- You (the grantor): The person who creates the trust and funds it with assets.
- Trustee: The person who manages the trust and distributes assets according to your instructions.
- Beneficiary: The person who receives benefits from the trust.
Here’s what makes a spendthrift trust different:
Your beneficiary can’t sell, give away, or pledge their interest in the trust.
Creditors generally can’t access the assets to pay off your beneficiary’s debts.
For example, instead of your son receiving $500,000 all at once, the trustee might distribute $3,000 monthly or pay for specific expenses like education, housing, or healthcare directly.
Who Needs a Spendthrift Trust?
Spendthrift trusts are especially useful when your beneficiary:
- Is young or financially immature.
- Has a history of poor money management.
- Struggles with addiction or gambling.
- Has significant debt problems.
- Works in a profession with high lawsuit risk.
- Might face a divorce down the road.
- Has special needs and receives government benefits.
- Is vulnerable to financial scams or exploitation.
The goal isn’t to punish or control your beneficiary. It’s to protect them (and the trust assets) from potential financial troubles.
Pros and Cons of Spendthrift Trusts
Advantages
1. Strong Asset Protection
The biggest benefit is protection from creditors. Since your beneficiary doesn’t technically own the assets in the trust, creditors generally can’t reach them until they are actually distributed. This shields your legacy from:
- Credit card companies.
- Lawsuit judgments.
- Bankruptcy proceedings.
- Most other types of debt collectors.
Even if your beneficiary faces financial disaster, the assets in the trust remain safe and can continue providing support.
2. Control Over Distributions
You get to set out conditions in the trust describing exactly how and when money gets distributed. The trustee is responsible for enforcing these provisions. Options include:
- Regular payments (monthly, quarterly, annually).
- Lump sums at specific ages (25, 30, 35, etc.).
- Funds for specific purposes (education, medical expenses, buying a home).
- Emergency distributions for unexpected needs.
These restrictions help prevent your hard-earned money from being squandered overnight.
3. Long-Term Financial Security
By pacing distributions, you can ensure your beneficiary has support for years or even decades. This can be especially important for:
- Young beneficiaries who might lack financial experience.
- People who need lifetime support for medical conditions.
- Anyone who might otherwise spend a large inheritance quickly.
4. Potential Tax Benefits
While tax advantages aren’t the primary reason to create a spendthrift trust, there can be benefits:
- Assets in an irrevocable spendthrift trust are removed from your estate, potentially reducing estate taxes.
- Strategic distribution timing can help minimize tax impacts on beneficiaries.
5. Privacy Protection
Unlike wills, which become public record during probate, trust agreements remain private. This keeps your family’s financial details out of public view.
Disadvantages
1. Setup and Maintenance Costs
Creating and maintaining a spendthrift trust isn’t free:
- Legal fees to draft the trust properly (typically $2,000-$10,000 depending on complexity).
- Ongoing trustee fees if you use a professional (highly recommended to avoid family conflicts).
- Administrative expenses for tax filings and record keeping.
For smaller estates, these costs might outweigh the benefits.
2. Complexity
Spendthrift trusts are more complex than simple wills or basic trusts:
- Require careful drafting to ensure they function as intended.
- Need proper funding and asset titling.
- Generally require professional management.
3. Limited Beneficiary Control
The flipside of protection is restriction. Your beneficiary will have limited say over how assets are invested or distributed. This might cause frustration or family tension.
4. Not Absolute Protection
Spendthrift provisions don’t shield assets from every type of claim:
- Federal tax liens.
- Some state-specific exceptions like child support obligations or alimony payments.
5. Irrevocability Concerns
If you set up an irrevocable spendthrift trust, you generally can’t change your mind later. This loss of flexibility can be problematic if circumstances change dramatically.
In many cases, the only way to amend an irrevocable trust is to petition a court to let you do it, and there’s no guarantee the effort will be successful.
Setting Up a Spendthrift Trust
To create an effective spendthrift trust, follow these steps:
1. Define Your Goals
Be clear about what you’re trying to achieve:
- Who are you protecting, and from what?
- How long should the trust last?
- How much control do you want to retain?
- What distribution schedule makes sense?
2. Choose Your Trustee Carefully
The trustee has enormous responsibility. We highly recommend that you use a professional trustee – typically, a bank or trust company. If you’d like to keep some degree of family control over the trust assets, you can name a family member as the trust protector – someone with the authority to veto the trustee’s decisions or even replace the trustee.
Remember, the trustee will make decisions about money when you’re no longer around. Choose someone trustworthy, financially savvy, and likely to outlive you.
3. Draft the Trust Document
Work with an advisor who specializes in estate planning to create a proper trust document. This should include:
- A clear spendthrift clause.
- Detailed discretionary distribution instructions.
- Trustee powers and limitations.
- Successor trustee provisions.
- Trust termination conditions.
4. Fund the Trust
A trust only protects assets that are actually in it. You’ll need to:
- Transfer ownership of assets to the trust.
- Update beneficiary designations where appropriate.
- Retitle property, accounts, and other holdings.
5. Regular Review
Even an irrevocable trust should be reviewed periodically to ensure it still meets your goals and complies with current laws.
Common Spendthrift Trust Examples
Example 1: The Young Heir
John wants to leave $1 million to his 19-year-old grandson, Michael, but worries about giving so much money to someone so young. John creates a spendthrift trust that:
- Pays for Michael’s college expenses.
- Provides $3,000 monthly after graduation.
- Distributes additional funds at ages 30, 35, and 40.
- Allows emergency distributions for health issues.
This approach ensures Michael has support throughout young adulthood while protecting the bulk of the inheritance until he gains financial maturity.
Example 2: The Financially Vulnerable Beneficiary
Sarah wants to provide for her sister Emma, who has struggled with debt and financial management. Sarah creates a spendthrift trust that:
- Pays Emma’s rent directly to her landlord.
- Covers medical insurance premiums.
- Provides a modest monthly allowance.
- Makes additional funds available with trustee approval.
This structure ensures Emma’s basic needs are met while protecting the assets from potential creditors.
Spendthrift Trusts vs. Other Options
How does a spendthrift trust compare to other planning tools?
Spendthrift Trust vs. Living Trust
A living trust is often used to avoid probate. It’s revocable and thus offers very little asset protection so long as the grantor, the person who sets up the trust, is alive.
Spendthrift Trust vs. Special Needs Trust
A special needs trust:
- Specifically designed to supplement government benefits.
- Focused on maintaining benefit eligibility.
- Has stricter distribution rules.
- Sometimes includes spendthrift provisions too.
Spendthrift Trust vs. Spendthrift Discretionary Trust
A spendthrift trust without a discretionary provision requires the trustee to follow the literal wording of the trust instructions. The trustee can’t adapt distributions from the trust to changing circumstances. On the other hand, a spendthrift discretionary trust offers less certainty for beneficiaries.
Spendthrift Trust vs. Domestic Asset Protection Trust
Some trusts, called Domestic Asset Protection Trusts (DAPTs), let the person who creates the trust (the grantor) also be one of the possible beneficiaries. In certain states, this setup can protect the trust’s assets from creditors—even while the grantor is still alive.
More than 20 states currently have laws that allow DAPTs. But in states without these laws, a person usually can’t create a trust, name themselves as a beneficiary, and expect those assets to be protected from creditors.
When someone sets up a trust and is also a beneficiary, it’s usually called a “self-settled trust.” These generally don’t offer asset protection unless they’re set up in a state that allows DAPTs.
Tax Implications of Spendthrift Trusts
Spendthrift trusts are irrevocable. This means:
- Assets are removed from your estate, potentially reducing estate taxes.
- Trust pays taxes on undistributed income.
- Beneficiaries pay taxes on distributions they receive.
- Tax rates for undistributed income in trusts reach the highest bracket at lower income levels.
The tax rules for trusts are complex and change frequently. Don’t make decisions based solely on tax considerations without professional guidance.
State Laws and Spendthrift Trusts
Spendthrift trust protection varies significantly by state. Some states offer strong protection, while others have more exceptions. The states with the strongest protection generally are those with DAPT laws in effect.
For example:
- The DAPT laws of Nevada, Alaska, and South Dakota have particularly strong trust protections.
- Many states exempt child support and alimony from spendthrift protection.
- Non-DAPT states limit protection for self-settled trusts (where you’re both grantor and beneficiary).
This is one area where consulting with an advisor familiar with your state’s laws is crucial.
The state law differences aren’t just legal technicalities—they can dramatically impact how well your trust works. For instance, California places significant limitations on spendthrift provisions, while Nevada offers some of the strongest protections in the country.
Your state of residence matters, as does the state where the trust is established and administered. In some cases, it might make sense to establish your trust in a state with stronger protections, even if you don’t live there. This approach requires careful planning and usually involves working with a trustee in that state.
Remember that state laws can also change over time. A trust that offered excellent protection when created might be affected by new legislation or court rulings years later. That’s why ongoing reviews with a knowledgeable advisor are essential to maintaining the effectiveness of your spendthrift trust.
Common Questions About Spendthrift Trusts
Can a spendthrift trust be changed or revoked?
Because a spendthrift trust is irrevocable, it generally cannot be changed once established, though some states allow modifications under specific circumstances
How long can a spendthrift trust last?
- Most states have “rule against perpetuities” laws limiting trust duration. This means a trust can’t last forever—it has to end after a set period so the assets eventually go to the beneficiaries.
- Some states allow trusts to last for many generations.
- A few states permit perpetual trusts that can theoretically last forever.
Can creditors ever reach assets in a spendthrift trust?
Yes, in some cases:
- Child support and alimony claims often trump spendthrift provisions.
- Federal tax liens may reach trust assets.
- Fraudulent transfer laws may apply if the trust was funded to avoid existing creditors.
- Once distributions are made to the beneficiary, those funds may be available to creditors.
Should I name a family member as trustee?
Probably not. Family members understand your intentions and charge little or nothing to serve. However, they may:
- Lack financial or administrative experience.
- Face pressure from beneficiaries.
- Have conflicts of interest.
- Die or become incapacitated themselves.
Consider using a professional trustee and naming a family member as the protector, thus combining family and professional oversight.
Is a Spendthrift Trust Right for You?
A spendthrift trust makes the most sense when:
- You have significant assets to protect.
- Your beneficiaries need financial guidance or protection.
- You prefer to distribute their inheritance over time rather than all at once.
- You’re concerned about potential creditor issues.
- You want long-term protection for your legacy.
But how do you really know if this is the right choice for your situation? Consider these real-world scenarios where spendthrift trusts have proven valuable:
The Professional Risk Case: If your beneficiary works in a high-liability profession—like medicine, law, or real estate development—a spendthrift trust can shield their inheritance from potential malpractice claims or business debts. Even careful professionals face lawsuits, and having protected assets can provide crucial security.
The Generational Wealth Case: For families building wealth that’s meant to last for generations, spendthrift provisions help prevent any single family member from depleting resources meant to support multiple generations. This isn’t about control—it’s about sustainability.
The Special Circumstances Case: Some beneficiaries have unique challenges, whether it’s a tendency toward impulsive decisions, vulnerability to influence from others, or chronic health issues that affect financial judgment. A spendthrift trust provides structure without stigma.
The best way to decide is to discuss your specific situation with an advisor who specializes in estate planning. They can help you weigh the costs, benefits, and alternatives based on your unique circumstances.
Alternatives to Consider
If a spendthrift trust doesn’t seem right for your situation, consider these alternatives:
1. Staged Inheritance
- Your will or regular trust can distribute assets in portions at different ages, like 1/3 at 25, 1/3 at 30, and 1/3 at 35.
- Pros: Simpler to set up, less administrative cost.
- Cons: Limited creditor protection, less flexibility.
2. Life Insurance Trust
- An irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT) holds life insurance proceeds for beneficiaries.
- Pros: Estate tax advantages, can include spendthrift provisions.
- Cons: Only works with life insurance, complex administration.
3. Direct Gifting Programs
- Give smaller amounts to beneficiaries during your lifetime.
- Pros: See how recipients handle money, use annual gift tax exclusions.
- Cons: No protection once gifts are made, limited amounts
4. Education Trusts
- Specifically fund educational expenses for children or grandchildren.
- Pros: Focused purpose, easier to administer.
- Cons: Limited to education expenses, less long-term protection.
Ready to Protect Your Legacy?
Spendthrift trusts aren’t for everyone, but they can be a powerful tool for protecting your assets and providing for loved ones who need financial guidance or protection.
They offer the unique combination of ongoing support for beneficiaries while shielding assets from creditors, poor decisions, and outside influences. For many families, this balanced approach provides peace of mind that their legacy will truly benefit their loved ones as intended.
We’ve found that the most successful spendthrift trusts share a few common traits:
- They’re designed with flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances.
- They balance protection with reasonable access to funds.
- They have clear, straightforward terms that minimize potential conflicts.
- They’re created with input from the beneficiaries when possible (to prevent resentment).
- They’re reviewed periodically to ensure they remain effective.
A spendthrift trust isn’t about controlling your beneficiaries’ lives or dictating their every financial move. It’s about creating a framework that helps them succeed while protecting them from financial pitfalls. When properly structured, these trusts don’t feel restrictive to beneficiaries—they feel supportive.
In an increasingly complex financial world, with rising debt levels, increasing divorce rates, and a litigation-happy culture, the protection offered by spendthrift trusts is more valuable than ever. Think of it as financial insurance for the next generation.
Like many estate planning tools, spendthrift trusts work best when thoughtfully designed for your specific situation. Get in touch to determine if this approach makes sense for your family and goals.
Remember, the goal isn’t to control from beyond the grave—it’s to provide support and protection for the people you care about most. A well-designed spendthrift trust can help achieve that balance.
If you’d like to discuss whether a spendthrift trust might fit into your wealth protection strategy, reach out to schedule a consultation. We’ve been helping clients protect their assets for over four decades.
About The Author
Need Help?
We have 40+ years experience helping Americans move, live and invest internationally…
Need Help?
We have 40+ years experience helping Americans move, live and invest internationally…
As Featured on
